2026 MLB Draft Steals: Top 10 Undervalued Picks You Need to Know! (2026)

The 2026 MLB Draft has come and gone, leaving fans and analysts alike to ponder the strategic moves made by each team. Among the many picks, several stand out as potential steals, offering a glimpse into the future of the sport. In this article, I'll delve into the top picks from the first 10 rounds, analyzing their potential impact and the strategic decisions behind them. From high school pitching prospects to power-hitting outfielders, these selections promise to shape the league in the years to come. Let's explore the gems that could become the next big stars in Major League Baseball.

The High School Arm: Gio Rojas

One of the most intriguing picks of the 2026 Draft was the Rangers' selection of Gio Rojas at No. 16 overall. As Jim Callis notes, the Rangers' decision to take a high school pitcher at this stage is a bold move, especially considering their recent draft history. Rojas, a left-handed pitcher, is considered one of the best high school arms in the class, and his selection at this spot suggests that the Rangers saw a unique opportunity to add a potential ace to their roster.

What makes Rojas particularly fascinating is his combination of size and athleticism. Standing tall at 6-foot-4, he possesses a powerful fastball that can reach triple digits. His ability to maintain control and accuracy, despite his size, is a rare trait among high school pitchers. As Callis suggests, the Rangers' decision to take a chance on Rojas could pay dividends in the future, especially if he continues to develop his command and control.

The Undervalued College Lefty: Hunter Dietz

The Yankees' selection of Hunter Dietz in the compensation round is another pick that warrants attention. Dietz, a left-handed pitcher, had a somewhat tumultuous college career, marked by injuries and limited playing time. However, as Callis points out, the Yankees saw potential in his raw talent and athletic ability. Dietz's ability to generate velocity and his overall athleticism make him a intriguing prospect, despite his limited track record.

What makes Dietz's selection particularly interesting is the Yankees' willingness to take a chance on a player who had not yet fully realized his potential. As Callis notes, the team's confidence in his ability to rebound and become a dominant left-handed pitcher is a testament to their scouting and development expertise. The Yankees' decision to take Dietz in the 35th round could prove to be a steal, especially if he can overcome his injuries and develop into a reliable starting pitcher.

The Young Shortstop: Rocco Maniscalco

The Cardinals' selection of Rocco Maniscalco in the second round is another pick that stands out as a potential steal. Maniscalco, a young and reclassified shortstop, impressed scouts with his defensive skills and overall athleticism. As Jonathan Mayo notes, his selection at No. 50 overall suggests that the Cardinals saw a first-round talent in a player who was overlooked due to his age and classification.

What makes Maniscalco particularly fascinating is his combination of size and speed. Standing at 6-foot-3, he possesses the arm strength and quickness to excel at shortstop. His selection by the Cardinals, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a long-term solution at the position. Maniscalco's potential to develop into a premier defensive shortstop could make him a key piece in the Cardinals' future plans.

The Power-Hitting Outfield: Gavin Grahovac

The Angels' selection of Gavin Grahovac in the third round is another pick that could pay dividends in the future. Grahovac, a power-hitting third baseman, impressed scouts with his raw power and bat speed. As Callis notes, his selection at No. 81 overall suggests that the Angels saw a potential star in a player who had a tumultuous college career due to injuries.

What makes Grahovac particularly fascinating is his ability to hit for power and average. Despite his injuries, he managed to hit 22 home runs in his return to college baseball. His selection by the Angels, a team known for its offensive-minded approach, suggests that they see him as a potential cornerstone of their future lineup. Grahovac's ability to hit for power and average could make him a key piece in the Angels' plans to rebuild and contend in the coming years.

The High School Catcher: Will Brick

The Blue Jays' selection of Will Brick in the fourth round is another pick that stands out as a potential steal. Brick, a high school catcher, impressed scouts with his defensive skills and raw power. As Mayo notes, his selection at No. 131 overall suggests that the Blue Jays saw a second-round talent in a player who was overlooked due to their lack of a second-round pick.

What makes Brick particularly fascinating is his combination of size and athleticism. Standing at 6-foot-4, he possesses the arm strength and quickness to excel behind the plate. His selection by the Blue Jays, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a long-term solution at the position. Brick's potential to develop into a premier defensive catcher could make him a key piece in the Blue Jays' future plans.

The Athletic Outfielder: Will Gasparino

The Phillies' selection of Will Gasparino in the fifth round is another pick that could pay dividends in the future. Gasparino, an athletic outfielder, impressed scouts with his raw power and overall athleticism. As Callis notes, his selection at No. 161 overall suggests that the Phillies saw a potential All-Star in a player who had some swing-and-miss issues.

What makes Gasparino particularly fascinating is his ability to combine size and speed. Standing at 6-foot-6, he possesses the raw power and athleticism to excel in the outfield. His selection by the Phillies, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential cornerstone of their future lineup. Gasparino's ability to develop into a premier outfielder could make him a key piece in the Phillies' plans to contend in the coming years.

The Athletic Left-Hander: Kyle Johnson

The Rays' selection of Kyle Johnson in the sixth round is another pick that stands out as a potential steal. Johnson, an athletic left-handed pitcher, impressed scouts with his raw stuff and overall athleticism. As Mayo notes, his selection at No. 174 overall suggests that the Rays saw a premium talent in a player who struggled performance-wise at Virginia.

What makes Johnson particularly fascinating is his ability to combine athleticism and raw stuff. Despite his struggles at Virginia, he possesses a powerful fastball and a good splitter. His selection by the Rays, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential bullpen arm or starting pitcher. Johnson's ability to develop into a reliable left-handed pitcher could make him a key piece in the Rays' future plans.

The Power-Throwing Right-Hander: Savion Sims

The Guardians' selection of Savion Sims in the seventh round is another pick that could pay dividends in the future. Sims, a power-throwing right-hander, impressed scouts with his raw velocity and overall athleticism. As Callis notes, his selection at No. 213 overall suggests that the Guardians saw a potential ace in a player who is still developing.

What makes Sims particularly fascinating is his ability to throw hard and with ease. Standing at 6-foot-8, he possesses a powerful fastball that can reach triple digits. His selection by the Guardians, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential long-term solution at the position. Sims' ability to develop into a premier right-hander could make him a key piece in the Guardians' future plans.

The Power-Hitting Shortstop: Will Plunkett

The Orioles' selection of Will Plunkett in the eighth round is another pick that stands out as a potential steal. Plunkett, a power-hitting shortstop, impressed scouts with his raw power and overall athleticism. As Mayo notes, his selection at No. 230 overall suggests that the Orioles saw a potential star in a player who is still developing.

What makes Plunkett particularly fascinating is his ability to hit for power and average. Despite his lack of experience at the position, he possesses the raw power and athleticism to excel at shortstop. His selection by the Orioles, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential cornerstone of their future lineup. Plunkett's ability to develop into a premier shortstop could make him a key piece in the Orioles' plans to rebuild and contend in the coming years.

The Power-Hitting Outfielder: Martin Shelar

The Red Sox's selection of Martin Shelar in the ninth round is another pick that could pay dividends in the future. Shelar, a power-hitting outfielder, impressed scouts with his raw power and overall athleticism. As Callis notes, his selection at No. 274 overall suggests that the Red Sox saw a potential star in a player who is still developing.

What makes Shelar particularly fascinating is his ability to hit for power and average. Standing at 6-foot-2, he possesses the raw power and athleticism to excel in the outfield. His selection by the Red Sox, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential cornerstone of their future lineup. Shelar's ability to develop into a premier outfielder could make him a key piece in the Red Sox' plans to contend in the coming years.

The Relief Arm: Nick Bonn

The Cardinals' selection of Nick Bonn in the tenth round is another pick that stands out as a potential steal. Bonn, a relief arm, impressed scouts with his raw velocity and overall control. As Mayo notes, his selection at No. 294 overall suggests that the Cardinals saw a potential bullpen arm in a player who is still developing.

What makes Bonn particularly fascinating is his ability to throw hard and with control. Despite his limited experience as a reliever, he possesses a powerful fastball and a good splitter. His selection by the Cardinals, a team known for its strong farm system, suggests that they see him as a potential bullpen arm. Bonn's ability to develop into a reliable reliever could make him a key piece in the Cardinals' future plans.

Conclusion

The 2026 MLB Draft has provided a glimpse into the future of the sport, with several teams making bold moves and selecting potential steals. From high school pitchers to power-hitting outfielders, these picks promise to shape the league in the years to come. As fans and analysts alike continue to analyze and interpret these selections, one thing is clear: the future of Major League Baseball is bright, and these young talents will play a key role in shaping it.

2026 MLB Draft Steals: Top 10 Undervalued Picks You Need to Know! (2026)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Maia Crooks Jr

Last Updated:

Views: 6472

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Maia Crooks Jr

Birthday: 1997-09-21

Address: 93119 Joseph Street, Peggyfurt, NC 11582

Phone: +2983088926881

Job: Principal Design Liaison

Hobby: Web surfing, Skiing, role-playing games, Sketching, Polo, Sewing, Genealogy

Introduction: My name is Maia Crooks Jr, I am a homely, joyous, shiny, successful, hilarious, thoughtful, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.